Swish purification and concentrates of impurities made using swish TLC could usefully be studied using constant boiling azeotropic mixtures which are predominantly either water or hydrocarbons but contain small amounts of other solvents which could provide a useful boost to the overall solvency. Hydrotropes with an appropriately controlled amount of organic ingredients to increase organic solubility could be used in the same way for swishing.
Examples of azeotropes that might be expected to only dissolve small amounts of many organics might be:
97.0% water; 3.0% acetic acid azeotrope bp 76.6 C
91.0% water; 9.0% Benzyl alcohol azeotrope bp 99.9ºC
95.5% hexane; 4.5% allyl alcohol azeotrope bp 65.5ºC
97% hexane 3% 1-butanol azeotrope bp 67.0ºC
94.5% carbon tetrachloride; 5.5% isobutanol bp 75.8 C
96.0% hexane; 4.0% propanol bp 65.7 C
90.0% water ;10.0% 1-octane bp 99.4 C
These constant boiling mixtures are selected because each one is either predominantly water, a hydrocarbon or carbon tetrachloride. They should be tested for their usefulness for swishing. None of these separate into two phases on standing at room temperature.
Another class of anti-solvents that might be tested for use in swishing are hydrotropes. Aqueous solutions of such compounds as
aromatic sulfonate salts
aromatic sulfonic acids
salts of benzoic acid and substituted benzoic acid
glycols
urea
4-isopropylbenzenesulfonic acid calcium salt
2,4-dimethylbenzenesulfonic acid sodium salt 40%
p-toluenesulfonate sodium
ethylene glycol monobutyl ether O-sulfonate potassium
potassium saliscylic acid
Each made up at an appropriate concentration to only dissolve a small amount of sample.